Campaigners hit out as figures reveal Cornwall Council spent £6m on agency staff

Trusted article source icon
Monday, March 07, 2011
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

Cash-strapped Cornwall Council spent nearly £6 million in two months paying consultants and agency staff, new figures have revealed.

The council, which recently approved plans to make £110 million worth of savings, is spending just under £70,000 per day on consultants, as well as more than £27,500 daily on temporary staff.

The figures lift the veil on council expenditure for the first time, after local government secretary Eric Pickles ordered all authorities to publish details of every expenditure over £500.

The council said consultants have played a valuable role in saving the taxpayer money, and say its consultants bill – which, over two months, is more than four times that for Devon – is being reduced.

But campaigners have said money is being "wasted".

Several thousand entries are listed on spread sheets published on Cornwall Council's website, which reveal the authority spent £2,396,002.08 on consultants in December, and a further £1,777,744.30 the following month.

The two-month total includes five six-figure payments to consultants – including one of £850,294 to the doomed South West Regional Development Agency, listed to be spent on the county's flagship Tremough Innovation Centre, designed to attract multi-million-pound economic growth in Cornwall.

In the same two-months Devon County Council made just two, five-figure payments to consultants – the highest being £151,303.68 to legal firm Burges Salmon LLP. In total, its receipts for consultants over £500 was £992,019.31.

Spends on agency staff also figure heavily in both authorities' recorded outgoings. Cornwall Council forecasts to lose about 2,000 workers in the next four years, with an estimated 500 employees expected to be made redundant.

But that has not stopped the authority spending more than £1.7 million on temporary staff in December and January.

According to the council's own figures, receipts for agency staff over £500 totalled £1,126,028 in December, and £578,416.50 in January.

These include six, six-figure payments to Comensura, a Luton-based company which, rather than provide its own staff, scours a bank of temporary workers with suitable qualifications to fit the council's needs.

By comparison Devon County Council's spending on agency staff was about one-eighth of Cornwall's. In a statement, Cornwall Council said the authority used "a software system to manage the administration of the recruitment process, enabling the council to make a single payment to Comensura rather than making individual payments to a number of different agencies". It said this approach was expected to save "more than £2 million over the next three years".

Council leader Alec Robertson said: "We have nothing to hide." He added the way the information was presented meant the term "consultants" was used to describe a range of organisations carrying out "vital work" for Cornwall.

He said: "The organisations referred to here offer expertise in specific areas.

"We use external companies for specialist type of work, this is cost-effective and saves the taxpayer money. Bringing in people on a project by project basis rather than employing them permanently will help save millions of pounds off council tax bills."

The council's own catalogue of expenditure also throws up some eyebrow-raising payments. The limited scope of the documents presented on every authority's websites offer only scant details about payments over £500.

For example Cornwall Council lists paying £1,000 for "Scary Little Girls" – a Cornish- and London-based drama group which provided pre-Christmas street entertainment in St Austell.

John O'Connell, research director of the campaign group TaxPayers' Alliance, said: "These are big bills for taxpayers to foot for just two months.

"Of course outside expertise may be necessary at times in specific fields like engineering and construction but the local authority has a planning department with well-paid bosses heading it up.

"Taxpayers already pay out huge sums for these executives, and they claim to be worth these salaries, so it will worry taxpayers that they are expected to fund such big monthly bills for consultants as well. Money is being wasted somewhere."

13
Tweet this article
Report

13 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Mossy, Bodmin

    Wednesday, March 09 2011, 10:15PM

    “More disgrace! And certain officers at the council want to promote and contribute to a multimillion pound stadium for Cornwall. What about putting the money to better use such as more employment, affordable housing, health etc in these difficult economic times. These are important and key to a long term prosperous Cornwall. Stop wasting tax payers money and start thinking about the wellbeing of the Cornish people.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Justin S###p, Camborne

    Wednesday, March 09 2011, 2:32PM

    “Any monkey can do this job


    http://www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news/163-6m-council-agency-staff/article-3299985-detail/article.html”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Justin S###p, Camborne

    Wednesday, March 09 2011, 11:56AM

    “In response to last point, I am a temp at the Council,and it is cheaper to have us as yes the agency gets just under £9 a hour, of which I get £6.40, but I dont get paid for bank holidays like Council staff and the council dont pay national insurance, paid sickness, so I get 11500 pa with no benefits but permanant get at least 16500 pa plus loads of benefits,need I go on, and we can be got rid of a lot easer and cheaper than permanant staff, and the council train us up and the private sector then benefit because we all looking for permanant jobs and so the council then have to pay for more new temp staff and more training, and customers ringing up getting frustrated because we say can't help them due to not getting the level of training that permanant staff get and the new temps take a while to get trained up again, you really don't want to see the sambles that is Cornwall Council and the way it is causing low morale in the staff, so temps are cheaper by the dozen so to speak!!”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by cheekyman, Redruth

    Tuesday, March 08 2011, 2:06PM

    “I work for a consultancy firm and we charge less for the work we do for Cornwall Council than CC would pay it's own staff...I always figured that what using a consultancy was for.
    We do, however, notice a lot of work outsourced to English firms who charge between 4 and 10 times the amount that we do for the same work.
    I personally think that the main trouble is money not staying local and the fact that agency wages are around 50% more per hour than that of permanent staff. There's no value to CC or benefit to the public in that.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Andy, St Austell

    Tuesday, March 08 2011, 9:42AM

    “Well, just more of the same, these idiots treat us with contempt, they think we will believe their pathetic excuses and lies. If they really got their act together, I wonder how much they would have to cut from the budget ? The whole council should be forced to resign, and should be re-elected, lavery should be fired, come on people of Cornwall, enough is enough.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Baz, Newlyn

    Monday, March 07 2011, 7:13PM

    “It seems a bit rotten that someone agrees to run the council for a nice salary then hires a consultant to do their job for them. We might as well get rid of CC all together and put the consultants in charge. That's where the real saving are.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Dave, Kent

    Monday, March 07 2011, 5:07PM

    “Presumably CCC have an "HR" department, are they that incompetent that they can't advertise and recruit staff themselves?”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by David, St Austell

    Monday, March 07 2011, 3:03PM

    “This is the same council that is making hundreds of Cornish workers redundant. It stinks to high heaven. The waste is unbelievable - £12million on unnecessary refurbishment of council offices - £12million on a solar farm that will not earn its keep - and now this revelation.
    I really despair for the council taxpayers of Cornwall they deserve better than this.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Wendy Creed, Truro

    Monday, March 07 2011, 2:25PM

    “No real surprises then .. 18 months ago I was staying in Liskeard and met at least 3 people who had come down from Liverpool to make a disabled access ramp somewhere in town and another two agency staff from London who were being employed to run the council tax side of things there - their B&B and travel expenses were all part of the job but they told me that they were NOT council tax specialists, just temp staff who were having to learn the ropes., hold on, how many unemployed are there in Liskeard alone that with training, could have done the job themselves?”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Al, Torpoint

    Monday, March 07 2011, 2:24PM

    “Years ago some bright spark advertised a get rich quick scheme. Send him a £1
    and he'd send his secret to you. When you opened the letter a slip of paper was revealed. It said ,"Do what I've ddone!" Now I know where the bright spark went. He got a job as a consultant!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters