Bards blast Cornish logo

Trusted article source icon
Monday, July 07, 2008
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

As tempers flare in Cornwall over the logo

for the new super council, the county's Grand Bard has joined

the opposition.

Vanessa Beeman wrote a letter to council leader David

Whalley expressing her fears that some people felt they were

being stripped of their identity and has called for the interim

executive to reconsider its decision.

On April 1 next year, Cornwall County Council and the six

district councils will make way for one unitary authority.

"color: rgb(0, 0, 0); text-decoration: none;">

"main2">The authority's new logo has been criticised by people

who say it does not fully represent Cornwall, with some

likening the design to the hairstyles of singer Amy Winehouse

and American boxing promoter Don King.

align="right" height="131" width="250">Mrs Beeman wrote: "It is

important that any marque adopted by the new council describes

and evokes the essence of Cornwall because it is an

international symbol which signifies a place and a culture

which has a strong and growing international dimension.

"As Grand Bard, I sense that I am speaking on behalf of both

the College of Bards and a wide cross-section of Cornish

society in asking that the interim executive reconsider its

decision and commission a new modern rendition of the

traditional crest, including the fisherman and miner and the

Cornish language, and with the addition of an evocation of the

symbol of St Piran."

Cornwall County Council says the logo is "inspiring and

dynamic, bringing a contemporary modern feel to the best of

Cornish tradition."

The Gorsedd of Bards, which upholds Celtic traditions in

Cornwall, promotes Cornish language, literature, music and

history. While the not-for-profit group recognised the proposed

logo was well-designed and, "in a benign way", sympathetic to

Cornish culture and its Celtic roots, it felt it was

insufficient in portraying the depth or range of Cornish

identity and heritage.

alt="" height="177" width="200">

"http://content.thisis.co.uk/Devon07/logo51.jpg" height="157"

width="200">

Left, traditional Cornwall Coat of Arms and the

current council logo

Mrs Beeman continued: "We strongly assert that, as the

Cornish language has been recognised by the Council of Europe,

and its future development is funded by the British Government,

and it is clearly and widely identified with modern Cornwall,

that any marque of any public sector body with specific

responsibilities for Cornwall should be using Kernewek (the

Cornish language) in its insignia and, in appropriate ways, in

its communications, promotions and presentations of

Cornwall.

"Gorseth Kernow feels that any marque for the new council

should embody a very strong sense of the civic and

constitutional identity of Cornwall, as well as an evocation of

culture and heritage.

"It should be able to evoke pride and recognition amongst

Cornish folk in Cornwall and amongst lovers, customers,

colleagues, ex-pats and descendants around the world."

The Grand Bard said the Gorsedd recognised it was important

to deploy modern design values and techniques in developing a

corporate image for the new authority.

But she added: "We feel that a reworking of the familiar,

well-known, widely recognised and much-loved crest assemblage

would be more appropriate and that this might include the

addition of a reference to the St Piran's Cross which has

become so widely associated with the positive outward-facing

cultural values of modern Cornwall."

83
Tweet this article
Report

83 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Steve Willimott, Doncaster

    Tuesday, January 20 2009, 9:50PM

    “They say the colours reflect the Cornish tartan. I thought it was black and yellow, not black, ochre and mud.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Melanie, Truro

    Wednesday, January 14 2009, 12:00PM

    “I think the new idea is awful! it looks like the villians hair in the incredibles - I much prefer the current tradional one”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by R Johnson, Fowey

    Monday, December 01 2008, 8:47PM

    “Stand fast Cornwall, dont let our traditions go.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Stehen Watts, Antony

    Wednesday, November 19 2008, 8:04PM

    “It looks like sabotage, the loss of a proud Cornish Identity. It seems to me that OUR representatives are not representing or listening to the people. If our councillors do not care about our Cornish Traditions and Heritage, then one must ask the question how they may run Cornwall. Will they treat everything else Cornish with equal contempt. Also one must ask, WHAT DID IT COST. We have a fantastic logo which undeniably reads and conveys the message Cornwall, its everything Cornwall is. It will cost nothing to keep and the new one has probably cost £200,000 already without changing livery on vehicles, signage and headed paperwork etc. Keep the current Logo; get rid of the council that 80% of the population of Cornwall didn't want”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Dorothy Gill-Carey, St Agnes

    Thursday, November 06 2008, 2:36PM

    “Why on earth can't they stick to the 15 balls on the sheild - it meaans Cornwall and is so simple and straight foreward.. Dorothy Gill-Carey, Penkerris, St Agnes TR5 0Pa”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by T, cornwall

    Sunday, July 13 2008, 9:01PM

    “I am not Cornish, but I have strong feelings that the traditions should stand firm....

    If you cannot be proud of where you are from and hold traditions, and your coat of arms in high esteem then perhaps we are not in the right place.

    As to why is ia fuss, sorry but where i am from, no-one cares and the county has been taken over and ripped apart. All the traditions shredded

    Please do not allow this to happen in cornwall

    be proud of your county and keep what is so precious, there is precious little left in England to be proud about”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Taumas Colliver, Grass Valley, California

    Saturday, July 12 2008, 4:18PM

    “Another example of an outsider majority government continuing in their attempts to erase the identity of a very rich culture.

    Just because the newly "proposed logo" is made of Cornish colors doesn't mean any more than a barber shop's red, white and blue candy stripe sign being symbolic of the American flag.

    If a logo is intended to present a meaningful explanation, then Kernow is burning.

    Simply reject it, Cornwall. Who says you have to fly it, use it on stationary, salute it, or whatever?

    Taumas Colliver
    Grass Valley, California”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Deg Peard, St Stephen

    Saturday, July 12 2008, 9:31AM

    “Chris Dunkerley, Australia. The main points of my arguments still stand. Why is nobody from Cornwall,and not from Eire, to be venerated as a 'cornish' champion? Which of FIVE different 'cornishes' can be definitively the 'true cornish'? Answer, they are all made up, to the delight of the Tourist Board!”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by mark lancaster, london

    Friday, July 11 2008, 2:04PM

    “Re: this logo debate, Intresting to see so much comment. As was once said: jaw jaw is better than war war!”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Denzil, Cornwall

    Friday, July 11 2008, 7:28AM

    “Yes, not many counties can say they have their own language - even less that have their own language and don't know how to speak it.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters