Eden and eco-town's incinerator link row as battle for 'green' energy begins

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, September 08, 2010
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

THE DEVELOPERS behind St Austell’s planned eco-town have not ruled out using energy from a proposed incinerator at St Dennis.

Eco-Bos, the company behind creating five small eco-towns across disused Imerys mining pits in St Austell and ‘clay country’ area, has confirmed that it will look at harnessing energy and heat created by an incinerator to fuel homes built as part of the eco-town.

Eco-Bos is made up of clay-mining giants Imerys, Egyptian developers Orascom, and the Eden Project – a leading light in sustainable resources, and at the forefront of eco-friendly ideas.

The revelation has sparked anger among objectors to the incinerator who claim Eden’s involvement contradicts its ethos.

However, a spokesman for the Eden Project said it is not against incineration per se, as a method of dealing with waste, but would favour, smaller and more local incinerators.

Cornwall councillor Dick Cole said it was nonsense for Eden to associate itself with the incinerator.

“The Eden Project claims to be a leading figure in green technology and yet through its association with Eco-Bos it’s quite happy to associate itself with a mass-burning incinerator for St Dennis.

“If the eco-town initiative and the Eden Project want to have any credibility at all, surely they need to distance themselves from the incinerator proposal as a matter of urgency.

“The incinerator is not sustainable, it’s backward looking, and we should be doing something much better in the 21st century,” he said.

However a spokesman for the Eden Project said the tourist attraction was not against incineration and how to deal with waste was a complex and pressing issue.

The spokesman said: “At the Eden Project we are not against waste incinerators as part of a palette of solutions, although we believe they should be local and small scale, but we recognise that the difficulty with dispersed solutions is that local objections cause even more barriers.”

Chairman of St Dennis Anti-Incineration Group (STIG) Pat Blanchard said the statement by the Eden project appeared to contradict Eden founder Tim Smit’s comments last year at a meeting of the St Austell Chamber of Commerce when he questioned the building of a mass-burning incinerator.

Mrs Blanchard said: “It is hard to believe that Eden is now considering endorsing the incinerator through its partners in Eco-Bos.

“If they are, perhaps they are not aware that the incinerator is incompatible with the Green Cornwall initiative and the Carbon Reduction programme. It would generate over 173,000 tonnes net CO2 every year, it is on a greenfield site and would depend entirely on road transport, requiring the construction of a dedicated haul road.

“There would be no pre-sorting of received waste, and any recyclables concealed in black bags would be destroyed. These facts alone would appear to be in direct conflict with the ethos of Eden.”

The idea of using the incinerator as an energy source for the eco-town was first mooted at the county’s most expensive planning inquiry into Cornwall’s Energy Recovery Centre, when SITA’s planning consultant Tim Greenwood let slip that discussions had been ongoing between SITA and Imerys.

At the inquiry in August Mr Greenwood even produced a letter dated from 2009 which proved discussions on the subject had taken place. Closing statements by all parties will be heard at the planning inquiry from October 5 to 7 in the One Stop Shop Council Offices in Penwinnick Road. The final decision is not expected to be made until Autumn 2011.

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by max power, st austell

    Sunday, September 12 2010, 11:02AM

    “Tim
    Although this story keeps appearing for different reasons I have thought the same thing, there has been very little input from STIG or residents who, I'm sure, could provide a different perspective and educate us further.
    Although STIG's website is impressive there's still more to do in presenting their propaganda. Sita has already presented their side illustrated with inexactitudes and was slammed by the ASA.
    Besides the health implications, there must be severe hardships through the decline of the local clay industry and the severe effect this has on house prices etc”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by TimV, Pz

    Friday, September 10 2010, 2:07PM

    “I am surprised, given the amount of local opposition, there hasn't been more comment on this story. What could be the explanation?”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by TimV, Pz

    Thursday, September 09 2010, 2:59PM

    “In theory, using waste to produce power and heat is a good idea. As always, the devil is in the detail. A tall chimney is an indication that the gases coming out are quite nasty. It relies on dispersion to minimise effects on the immediate environment. Most waste is now plastic, which burns but also produces dangerous dioxins, unless special technology is incorporated. Without pre-sorting, one is never absolutely sure what is being burned, including chemical and metal residues. The visual and other environmental impacts are also significant, particularly in a rural area. Edmonton in London has had one for many years and much monitoring has been done there. The more houses built and occupied, the more waste is produced. This should be borne in mind every new estate is proposed. Councils with the duty to dispose of the waste we produce, has an unenviable problem. If we can't cut down on the amount we create, it has to be disposed of somewhere and effectively this means either controlled tipping or incineration. If incineration is the chosen one it makes sense to utilize the heat, particularly if housing is planned nearby. Of course this no consolation for the people who live in the vicinity, who have to bear the brunt of our throw-away society.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by max power, st austell

    Wednesday, September 08 2010, 8:20PM

    “Sita, Imerys, Orascom, EDF and Eden what a tangled web they weave...
    EDF French power company with their green union jack (I thought that might be reserved for a UK co.?) who in partnership with Eden wishes to appear as green as they wished we were!
    Sita, French company inflicting their retro tech in one giant mass burn
    Imerys, French company, what a result, mining land and green fields for housing any remaining clay reserves buried forever under concrete
    Eden, what hypocrites, as the council advocates ''green Cornwall'' Eden advocates incineration with no sustainability and a carbon footprint bigger than all the senior officers of the Unitary put together (I think)
    Eco brothers my **** , the writing was on the wall when the survey for the haul road trashed trees, bushes, nesting boxes etc.
    What sheer arrogance they must think they own Cornwall.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters