Planning row puts ferry link to Isles of Scilly earmarked funding funding in danger

Trusted article source icon
Monday, July 26, 2010
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

Transport Secretary Philip Hammond has warned funding for the "lifeline" link between the Isles of Scilly and the mainland is at risk until the Battle of Battery Rocks is resolved, the Western Morning News can reveal.

Mr Hammond acknowledged that there is a "special case" to be made for protecting around £24 million of Department for Transport (DfT) cash earmarked for providing a ferry link between the Scillies and Cornwall.

But as plans to build a terminal in Penzance harbour for a new boat to the Isles of Scilly have yet to be approved, he stressed a decision cannot be made until a "clear scheme proposal" lands on his desk.

Speaking to the WMN, Mr Hammond indicated that the department would look favourably upon a scheme to accommodate a large ferry ship serving the islands once the present boats retire.

This is in stark contrast to almost all of scores of transport schemes suspended pending the Government's major spending review in October. Mr Hammond is refusing to give guarantees on the future of the Kingskerswell bypass in South Devon among many others.

Of the Scilly link, he said: "We recognise that it is a lifeline scheme. But it's a special case for another reason.

"It's one of only three schemes in the country that have conditional approval, which is the most advanced status other than full approval. It's right up there at the top of the list."

But he stressed the fact that the Government Office for the West Midlands, which handles approvals for the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, had yet to endorse the scheme is a "problem".

The plan to build a £40 million passenger and freight terminal at Battery Rocks, which would also unlock European cash, was finally sanctioned by Cornwall Council's strategic planning committee in March.

Delays stemmed from local protesters claiming the terminal would destroy a beach and a historic pier.

Fearing the worst, there have been suggestions that the terminal be spilt over two sites in Penzance or, controversially, the plan is transferred to Falmouth.

"The community hasn't actually decided what it wants to do yet," said Mr Hammond. "Which harbour it wants to enhance and where it wants to build the facilities, and whether it can get planning permission and listed building consent to do it.

"Frankly, until Cornwall Council and the local community can decide the way they are going, and get the approvals in place, there is no decision for us to take.

"We wouldn't take a decision before the spending review is concluded anyway. But even if the spending review were concluded tomorrow, there is no decision for the Secretary of State.

"I am confidently expecting that Cornwall Council will be able to resolve the outstanding issues and that by the time the spending review has been completed, there will be a clear scheme proposal put to my department."

On the South Devon bypass, a scheme in the offing for decades that has yet to achieve the first of three levels of DfT consent, Mr Hammond said he would wait for the conclusion of the spending review.

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by TimV, Pz

    Wednesday, July 28 2010, 2:31PM

    “Oh Parnassus I admire your logic! Because I live in the area affected, I am not competent to comment, but you, apparently with little knowledge of the details, are? This proposal was a lash-up from start to finish. It has cost two or three million pounds to date, very little of which has come anywhere near the Cornwall economy. The total cost of about £60m is again destined to find its way out of county and land ratepayers with ongoing cost, to service the loan and underwrite the operation of the new boat (built abroad). In the process ruining one of the finest features of a Cornish coastal resort. Now who do you think is crazy? Me, you or the originators of the scheme?”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Oh Parnasus, Mothership

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 5:15PM

    “Tim, as a PZ resident you are bound to have an initial reaction that is borne of emotion and local politicking, so I would advise that you are unable to take part in this conversation rationally.
    The planning decision should have been made by Whitehall, with documentation for the Secretary of State to consider, and away from the local circus whipped up by Penzance Council and John Magazines.
    There has to be a line of sanity, and when you start putting £24m projects on hold because some poor people believe a short stretch of beach with shopping trolleys on it is enchanted and magical, well then you forfeit your right to take part in adult conversations.
    I wonder how many pixies were made homeless to build the A30?
    Mad as a fish you lot are.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by TimV, Pz

    Monday, July 26 2010, 4:25PM

    “What hogwash "Oh Parnasus, Mothership". Too often funding for large projects does more harm than good. The proposals for Penzance, misconceived from the beginning, with more faults than the San Andreas, is a non starter. The sooner an acceptable scheme is put together the better.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Gary, Saltash

    Monday, July 26 2010, 3:42PM

    “First the leaks
    Then we moan
    Then comes acceptance
    Then the cuts followed by silent

    Just be honest and stop the leaks when delivering bad news”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Oh Parnasus, Mothership

    Monday, July 26 2010, 2:22PM

    “It's about time this was put to bed once and for all isn't it?
    It's an embarassment for the region when something as simple as this is dragged on for years.
    I also think that Penzance should be excluded from any attempt to apply for large grant funding for the next 5 years. Quite simply, if the region is going to delay or cancel projects when millions have been awarded, then the government has every right (and a duty) to know that large projects are going to be completed on time, and largely to budget. Penzance Town Council has shown that they value religion over regeneration and so, with that in mind, perhaps they can pray for things to happen rather than be given the money to DO something about local issues.
    The government can't just be handing out £24m to crackpot Councils, we'd get nowhere very fast.
    Let the Council of the Isles of Scilly have the £24m and let them decide how best to utilise it. You can't have a Route 'Partnership' when only one partner wants/needs something.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters