Squabbling council angers teen's father
THE father of a teenager who fell to his death from a Newquay cliff top has demanded an end to council squabbling over who should foot the £24,000 bill to make the town's cliffs safer.
John Higgins – father of 16-year-old Paddy Higgins who died this summer – has spoken of his frustration after learning that an argument has broken out between Newquay Town Council and Cornwall Council over who should pay to repair and install new fencing.
-

Paddy Higgins, who died after falling down cliffs.
Cornwall Council is expecting Newquay Town Council to pay 50% of the cost, but the town authority has refused – claiming it is 'double taxation'.
But Mr Higgins, who started an online petition to Downing Street in an attempt to make Newquay a safer place for teenagers, said the dispute needs to end.
"Newquay just needs to be looked at to make it safer for people visiting the town," he said.
"Maybe fencing is not the way forward but there are other things that can be looked at, which would be cheaper.
"Primarily, the easy access in places around Newquay to the beaches and cliff edges should be made safer before more tourists visit the area next summer."
Correspondence between the unitary authority and the town council has been ongoing for the last few months.
The safety issue came up after the deaths of 16-year-old Paddy, who was visiting Newquay with friends in July, and promising rugby player Andrew Curwell, 19, who was found dead at the bottom of Great Western Beach just eight days earlier, on June 28.
Cornwall Council says it would like to see fencing installed around Newquay's cliff edges in order to provide more adequate safety measures – at a cost of £24,000.
Newquay Town Councillor, Patrick Lambshead, said: "It's a knee jerk reaction from Cornwall Council regarding the sad events that took place in the summer.
"Some existing fences do need replacing, but you will see people climbing over the fences despite what anyone tries to do to stop them."
Mayor of Newquay, Cllr John Fitter, said at Wednesday's town council meeting: "No one from Cornwall Council asked anyone from the town council to accompany them while they came to Newquay. I think we need to send a message to Cornwall Council saying this behaviour will not be tolerated.
"What happened to the localism that was meant to come with Cornwall operating under unitary status? This would be double taxation for the people of Newquay and wrong."
Cllr Gary Redman, also speaking at Wednesday's meeting, said: "Fencing the coastline of Newquay will make no difference. I lost my cousin, Dominic Swanson, to the same problem of not realising what you are doing when under the influence of alcohol.
"It doesn't matter if you are from Newquay or Sheffield. Education about the dangers of the cliffs and not fencing is what is needed here to make Newquay safe."
In a statement, Mike East, Cornwall Council's head of environment, said: "We are trying to enhance safety provision in Newquay by maintaining and repairing coastal fences in the town in light of the tragic events this summer – obviously there is a cost attached to that.
"We thought it was appropriate to ask Newquay Town Council, as a stakeholder with a strong interest, to consider making a contribution to the cost of this work being carried out."








11 Comments
View all
by Jeff, Plymouth
Thursday, October 15 2009, 1:12PM
“This is a tragedy for the family involved but as it states in the story another lad was killed on the cliffs just 8 days before, yet the lad was still allowed to go to Newquay at 16. So there must be someone else to blame for the decsion the parents made that cost him his life! Newquay is a great place to go on holiday, to turn it into some form of Gulag where you are fenced in is madness.”
by ed, newquay
Thursday, October 15 2009, 11:02AM
“sad for families losses.
but don,t think fences are a cause or cure, does that mean we should fence the sea off because of the sad losses that have occured there.”
by Fiona, Newquay
Thursday, October 15 2009, 10:53AM
“How Sad that this is still an issue. Don't drink under age, and dont attempt to walk along the cliffs under the influence.”
by sam, Truro
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 3:50PM
“Quite simply a waste of £24k”
by michael polglase, blackwater truro
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 2:11PM
“tragic as the deaths may be, if a teenager is unable to behave reasonably then the parents should not have sent him of on his own!, it looks more and more like "its not my job/fault the council/government should do something about it!.”
by Steadkitten, Colchester
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 1:07PM
“Well L. Smith I don't know where else you think money comes into Cornwall from, it is certainley not from local taxation.”
by grace, Truro
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 12:00PM
“How high does a fence have to be to stop a detrmined person under the influence from trying to climb it? It was an accident and as said below plenty of people have enjoyed the coast and not fallen off. I do wonder if they had been struck down by a taxi or fallen under a train there would be such a fuss. Its a sad loss but these things happen everyday all over the world. Putting fences up will not stop youths coming to Newquay to get drunk and doing stupid things.”
by Mark B, Newquay
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 11:41AM
“Amanda - perfect comments made there.
People need to step back and stop playing the blame game.
I grew up in Newquay, I drank "under age", I also walked home via cliffs, as did lots of my friends.... the difference is we drank in moderation, and had the sense to not to climb over fences or act like lemmings.
If a person is "responsible enough" to be sent to Newquay alone/with friends, then they are also "responsible enough" to look after their own life. If it turns out they weren't responsible enough then it is either their own fault, or their parents for allowing them in the first place.
Potentially harsh, but certainly true. Sorry!”
by Reg, Pt
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 11:34AM
“I have to agree with Amanda. The recent loss of lives (plural losses) have, in the main, been down to user error and nothing to do with Council safety. I am afraid that alcohol and/or drugs - and inherrent stupid activities - do not go well together with cliff tops. Youngsters should be taught from a very early age (as I was when I was 3 up) that cliff tops are ugly and dangerous and unsafe if too close to the edge. 16 yearolds and up should have no need to be taught this - it is 100% clean and pure commonsense.”
by L Smith, Cornwall
Wednesday, October 14 2009, 11:34AM
“Again Cornwall will foot the bill.
Yet the "Tourist Lobby" always tell us how many "millions" of pounds tourism brings to benefit Cornwall. Joke.”