Supermarket chains 'squeezing farmers'

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, November 19, 2009
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

MAJOR supermarket chains have been attempting to squeeze farmers in an attempt to cut costs during the recession, a former buyer for Tesco has claimed, writes the WMN's Graeme Demianyk.

Michael Seymour, formerly the supermarket giant's buying manager for butter and fats, said large retailers were anxious to keep costs down an effort to retain customers and boost profits in straitened economic times.

Speaking in Cornwall, he said: "The economic climate is tough, and everyone wants their pound of flesh.

"Tesco is obsessed by margin, Asda is more interested in market share, and Morrisons just wants cash.

"It has been very aggressive for the past 12 to 15 months and they will be hammering suppliers on price."

Mr Seymour, who now runs the food business consultants Seymour Williams Associates, was explaining to Westcountry business leaders how suppliers could get their products into supermarkets and in front of other major buyers.

He was speaking to around 25 land agents and farmers on the rural leadership course run by Duchy College's Rural Business School.

Mr Seymour said the supermarkets were having to adapt to changing shopping habits caused by the recession.

As well as trading down to cheaper food and eating in more, hard-pressed consumers were also concerned about wastage, the environment and local sourcing. As a result, retailers were moving away from potentially wasteful buy-one-get-one-free promotions, often seen as wasteful, and seeking other ways to retain customers. Supermarkets wanted to make shopping easier for their customers, while also improving the bottom line, he went on.

However, there were still opportunities for innovative farmers to sell through the multiples, which offered tremendous opportunities for growth, he said. Local produce was still in strong demand, particularly in rural areas, but products must look good on the shelf, and be easy to handle with minimal wastage, he said.

A spokesman for Tesco dismissed the claim, saying: "We have thousands of suppliers, ranging from farmers and small companies delivering a single product directly to a few local stores, to large multinational companies whose products we stock in all our markets.

"Our customers want the best quality, choice and value for money. To provide this, we need strong relationships with reliable suppliers.

"We build long-term relationships with our suppliers, as we recognise that our success is linked to theirs."

A spokesman for Asda said it had a "fair, honest and open" relationship with suppliers and that it worked with them to provide the "best possible price" for customers.

A Morrisons spokesman said: "We are committed to working in partnership with our suppliers to ensure an outstanding offer to our customer in terms of quality, value, freshness and service. A good, positive relationship with our suppliers is vital to our success and we aim to be a loyal customer to our suppliers."

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Sarah, Surrey

    Thursday, November 19 2009, 9:38PM

    “A friend of mine worked for a farm in Kenya producing packaged herbs for the UK market. One of his neighbours produced tomatoes under contract for one of the big UK supermarkets. He showed my friend the specifications to which he had to work - a huge thick document stating in minute detail the size, colour and weight of each tomato. He pointed out, nowhere in this document was there any mention of flavour...”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Talbot Yancy, uk

    Thursday, November 19 2009, 12:20PM

    “Tomorrow's headline, 'sea is made of water, and it's salty'.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Talbot Yancy, uk

    Thursday, November 19 2009, 12:16PM

    “"MAJOR supermarket chains have been attempting to squeeze farmers in an attempt to cut costs "

    Oh, you think?”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Dave Joslin, St Austell

    Thursday, November 19 2009, 10:42AM

    “Of course they will deny it but supermarkets are as much a curse as a blessing. y selling below cost on offers they have put a lot of local traders out of business and yes they have squeezed the farmers by tying them to contracts to sell more cheaply than cost in some cases. Recently Wadebridge voted for another supermarket. What does a town of that size need with four supermarkets. Do they realise that money spent with local traders stays in the county whereas that spent in supermarkets goes out of Cornwall.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters